Top 7 Metrics for Outsourced Recruitment

Outsourcing recruitment can save time and improve hiring, but how do you measure success? Here are the 7 key metrics every business should track to evaluate outsourced recruitment performance:

1. Time-to-Hire: Measures how quickly positions are filled. Faster hiring reduces costs and ensures productivity.
2. Cost-per-Hire (CPH): Tracks total recruitment expenses per hire, including agency fees, technology, and compliance costs.
3. Hire Quality Score (HQS): Evaluates new hires' performance, skills, and alignment with company values.
4. Recruitment Channel Analysis (RCA): Identifies the most effective sourcing channels based on cost, quality, and retention.
5. Candidate Feedback Scores: Measures candidates’ experience during the hiring process to improve recruitment practices.
6. Job Offer Success Rate: Tracks how many candidates accept offers, reflecting the competitiveness and clarity of your offers.
7. New Hire Retention: Monitors how long new hires stay, highlighting the quality of hires and onboarding effectiveness.

These metrics help businesses optimize hiring costs, improve candidate quality, and boost employee retention. Start tracking these today to ensure your recruitment efforts deliver results.

What Metrics and Key Performance Indicators Do BPOs Use to Measure Recruitment Success?

1. Time-to-Hire

Time-to-Hire measures how long it takes to go from posting a job to having an offer accepted. It's a key metric for identifying areas to improve in your hiring process.

Cutting down on Time-to-Hire can save on vacancy costs, fill roles faster, maintain productivity, and create a smoother experience for candidates. To achieve this, keep a close eye on every stage of the recruitment process - from the moment a job is posted to when an offer is accepted. Spot any delays, set clear timelines, and communicate regularly with your recruitment team or partner.

For remote hiring, streamlined processes are especially important to handle time zone differences. Using modern recruitment tools, setting clear guidelines, and working with agencies like Remotely Talents can help make things run more smoothly.

While reviewing your Time-to-Hire, compare your data to industry standards to pinpoint delays. Just remember, speed is important, but it should never come at the expense of hiring the right person.

2. Cost-per-Hire

Cost-per-Hire (CPH) measures how much it costs to recruit by dividing total hiring expenses by the number of successful hires.

When calculating CPH for outsourced recruitment, pay attention to these expense categories:

• Direct costs: Fees for agencies, job postings, and assessment tools
• Administrative costs: Managing contracts and using communication platforms
• Technology costs: Systems like applicant tracking or video interview software
• Compliance costs: Background checks and employment verification processes

A proper CPH calculation includes both internal and external costs. For example, if you spend $5,000 on agency fees and $1,000 on technology to hire two people, your CPH would be $3,000.

To manage your Cost-per-Hire effectively without sacrificing quality, try these approaches:

• Monitor cost trends: Look for variations in CPH across roles, teams, or locations.
• Assess vendor performance: Compare recruitment partners to find the best balance of cost and results.
• Look beyond initial costs: Factor in retention rates to understand the long-term value of your hiring investments.

Remote hiring often lowers expenses like relocation or office setup but may require spending on digital onboarding and collaboration tools.

Keep in mind, the cheapest option isn’t always the best. Spending more upfront can lead to hiring higher-quality candidates who stay longer, offering better returns over time. Use a consistent tracking system for all hiring expenses and regularly review CPH trends - monthly or quarterly - to find savings while maintaining quality.

3. Hire Quality Score

The Hire Quality Score (HQS) is a key metric that evaluates how well a candidate fits your organization, going beyond just speed and cost metrics like Time-to-Hire and Cost-per-Hire. It focuses on candidate effectiveness and how well they align with your company, making it a critical measure for long-term recruitment success.

HQS evaluates two main areas:

• Performance: Includes metrics like first 90-day productivity, time to reach full productivity, role-specific KPIs, and adherence to processes.
• Cultural Alignment: Assesses how well the candidate integrates with the team, communicates, aligns with company values, and adapts to remote or in-office environments.

How to Calculate HQS

You can calculate HQS by assigning weights to each criterion based on your priorities and then scoring candidates. Here's an example:

Regularly tracking HQS (e.g., monthly) helps you identify patterns. A drop in HQS might highlight issues like unclear job descriptions, ineffective screening, communication barriers, or onboarding challenges.

Tips for Monitoring HQS

• Use standardized evaluation forms for consistency.
• Conduct structured reviews at 30, 60, and 90 days.
• Schedule regular check-ins with new hires and their supervisors to gather feedback and address any concerns early on.

This approach ensures you maintain a high standard in your recruitment process while continuously improving outcomes.

sbb-itb-88a7fe6

4. Recruitment Channel Analysis

Recruitment Channel Analysis (RCA) helps you measure how well your talent sourcing efforts are working, manage recruitment budgets, and identify the most effective channels for finding candidates.

Key Metrics to Monitor

When evaluating recruitment channels, focus on these key metrics to get meaningful insights:

Assessing Channel Performance

Recruitment channels can be grouped into the following categories:

• Job Boards: Platforms like LinkedIn, Indeed, and Glassdoor.
• Professional Networks: Industry-specific platforms and alumni networks.
• Referral Programs: Employee recommendations, often a reliable source of quality hires.
• Recruitment Partners: Outsourcing firms or agencies, such as Remotely Talents, which connects businesses with remote professionals in Europe and Latin America.
• Social Media: Includes career pages and targeted ads on platforms like Facebook or Instagram.
• Direct Sourcing: Internal efforts by your talent acquisition team to identify and engage candidates directly.

These categories, paired with the metrics above, provide a clear picture of which channels are delivering the best results.

Strategies for Improvement

To maximize the effectiveness of your recruitment channels, consider these steps:

• Set Clear KPIs for Each Channel: Establish measurable goals based on past performance and industry standards.
• Conduct Regular Reviews: Periodically evaluate how each channel is performing and reallocate resources as needed.
• Analyze All Costs: Account for visible and hidden costs, such as staff time and software tools, to get the full picture.
• Track Quality: Look beyond volume and focus on the quality of hires from each channel to identify the most reliable sources.

Best Practices for Data Collection

To ensure accurate data, use tracking codes, maintain consistent attribution methods, log candidate sources at the first point of contact, monitor their progress through the hiring funnel, and account for seasonal trends that might affect results.

5. Candidate Feedback Scores

Beyond tracking efficiency and costs, understanding candidate feedback provides a crucial look at the quality of your recruitment process. It highlights what's working and where improvements are needed, offering a well-rounded view when paired with operational metrics.

Key Feedback Dimensions

Focus on these areas to evaluate the candidate experience:

Collection Methods

Use structured tools to gather feedback effectively:

• Post-Interview Surveys: Send within 24 hours after the interview for fresh insights.
• Stage Completion Forms: Collect input at key milestones in the process.
• Exit Surveys: Hear from candidates who drop out for insights on their decision.
• Post-Decision Feedback: Gather perspectives from both successful and declined candidates.

Measuring Impact

Keep an eye on these indicators to assess feedback effectiveness:

• Response Rates: Aim for at least 60% participation.
• Sentiment Analysis: Track trends in positive and negative feedback.
• Recurring Issues: Identify patterns in complaints or concerns.
• Resolution Speed: Monitor how quickly issues are addressed.

Turning Feedback Into Action

Here’s how to use the data to improve:

1. Regularly review feedback on a monthly basis.
2. Group issues by how often they occur and their impact on the process.
3. Adjust recruitment practices based on recurring themes.
4. Refine communication strategies and candidate touchpoints.
5. Identify and address recruiter training gaps to enhance interactions.

6. Job Offer Success Rate

The job offer acceptance rate shows how many candidates say "yes" to your offers. It reflects how well you're screening candidates, how appealing your compensation is, and how clear your communication has been.

Breaking Down the Metrics

Here are some key metrics to keep an eye on:

• Initial offer acceptance: Percentage of candidates who accept your first offer.
• Final offer closure: Percentage of candidates who formally accept after negotiations.
• Time to accept: How many business days candidates take to decide.
• Counter-offer rate: How often candidates ask for changes to your offer.
• Offer withdrawal rate: Percentage of candidates who decline or back out after initially accepting.

These numbers help you understand what’s working and what needs fixing in your hiring process.

What Drives Success?

To boost your acceptance rate, focus on these:

• Offer competitive pay and benefits.
• Present offers quickly and clearly in writing.
• Keep in touch with candidates as they decide.

Red Flags to Watch For

Pay attention to:

• A high number of counter-offers or withdrawals, which could mean your offers aren’t appealing.
• Long decision times, which might point to unclear communication or hesitation.

Ways to Improve

You can improve your offer acceptance rate by:

• Setting clear expectations early on.
• Reducing the time between final interviews and extending offers.
• Personalizing offers to fit what candidates value most.

How to Calculate It

Use this formula to measure your success:

Offer Success Rate = (Accepted Offers ÷ Total Offers Extended) × 100

7. New Hire Retention

New hire retention is a strong indicator of how well outsourced recruitment is working. By measuring how long new employees stay with your company, you can assess whether your recruitment partner is finding candidates who align with your workplace culture and job requirements.

Metrics to Watch

Keep an eye on these timeframes to evaluate retention:

• 30-day retention: Reflects how well new hires fit in and adapt during onboarding.
• 90-day retention: Indicates how well they adjust to the company culture and role.
• First-year retention: Highlights the overall success of the hiring process.
• Average tenure: Shows how long employees typically stay.

How to Calculate Retention Rate

Use this formula to calculate your retention rate:

Retention Rate = ((Total New Hires - Departures) ÷ Total New Hires) × 100

Red Flags to Watch For

Certain patterns can signal trouble with retention:

• High turnover within the first 90 days.
• Frequent feedback about mismatched job expectations.
• Early exits concentrated in specific teams or departments.
• Turnover rates higher than those of directly hired employees.

Addressing these issues quickly can help improve retention rates.

Steps to Improve Retention

Here are some practical ways to ensure employees stick around:

• Clarify Roles
  Provide detailed job descriptions, set clear expectations, and outline career growth opportunities.
• Strengthen Onboarding
  Use structured onboarding programs, assign mentors, and schedule regular check-ins within the first 90 days.
• Focus on Cultural Fit
  Make culture a priority during candidate screening, encourage team connections, and offer additional support for remote employees.

Specialized agencies like Remotely Talents can help refine these practices by matching candidates who are a good fit for your organization.

The Cost of Poor Retention

When retention is low, costs go up. You’ll face higher replacement expenses, reduced productivity, increased training costs, and even a dip in team morale.

Setting Retention Goals

To measure success, aim for these benchmarks:

• 90% retention after 30 days.
• 85% retention after 90 days.
• 75% retention after one year.

Compare your results to these targets regularly to evaluate the effectiveness of your recruitment strategy and ensure you’re building a team that lasts.

Wrapping It Up

The seven metrics outlined above create a clear framework for evaluating and improving your outsourced recruitment efforts. They provide actionable insights to help you make better hiring decisions.

Why Data Matters in Recruitment

Tracking these metrics effectively can lower hiring costs, speed up the hiring process, boost candidate quality, improve retention rates, and maximize your recruitment ROI.

How to Track Metrics Effectively

Recruitment experts can simplify the process of tracking and refining these metrics. For instance, Remotely Talents takes a structured approach to ensure efficient hiring. As Pete Geherin, Vice President at TradeCentric, shared:

The team was knowledgeable, responsive, professional, and easy to work with.

Real-World Results

Using a metrics-driven approach leads to clear improvements in hiring outcomes. This includes better candidate quality and smoother recruitment processes, which consistently deliver strong results.

Lessons from Experience

Client feedback shows how data-driven recruitment strategies work in practice. These real-world examples highlight the practical advantages of focusing on key metrics.

Next Steps

To enhance your recruitment process, consider these steps:

• Set specific benchmarks for success
• Regularly review and analyze your data
• Adjust your strategies based on insights
• Partner with experienced industry professionals

Related Blog Posts

• Top Tech Recruitment Firms for Remote Talent in 2025
• 12 Best Remote Recruitment Agencies to Hire Global Talent
• Why Outsourcing Recruitment to an Agency Can Save You Time and Money
• 7 Best Recruitment Agencies for StartUps